To indie or not to indie . . . whether ’tis nobler

I spent a lot of time yesterday reading about self-publishing versus traditional publishing, and trying to become comfortable with a decision on which way to go.

For me, it boils down to prestige versus control. I realize this is a very simplified view.

Traditional Publishing

With traditional publishing you get prestige (and a lot of other help with the nuts and bolts of actually printing and distributing your book.) But when you can list a bona fide, tried and true publisher on the inside page of your book, you gain prestige. Someone in-the-know deemed your manuscript as publication worthy.

If all your life you had a dream of becoming a published author, publishing a book yourself may not fulfill that dream, depending on how you look at it.

But if you are never able to hook an agent with your one-shot-at-it brilliant first paragraph in your query letter that lies somewhere in a stack of hundreds of the same, you will never get a publisher, and you will also never fulfill that dream.

Quality Concerns

Since anyone can publish anything today, the question of a standard of quality also comes into play. With traditional publishing, one of the roles the agents and editors, who function as gatekeepers, play is to maintain a level of quality. They want their company to have a good reputation by printing quality stories.

Richard P. Hughes addresses the quality or validation issue, and the importance of having beta readers, in this short, and clever, blog post from Writing and Living:

April Hamilton, author of the Indie Author Guide Publetariat  poses the questions, Is your book ready? Are you and your plaform ready? Or are you going to make the rest of us look bad? in her “All the Cool Kids are Doing Itblog post that appeared in


One thing is certain if you self-publish—your book will be published. It may not sell, but it will be out there. And if you want to spend the rest of your life promoting it, you can. You have control of the title, what is in the book, how it is distributed, how it is marketed, and for how long. You will, however, likely be banned from the brick and mortar book stores. There are some places where Indies are just not welcome.

You will also have to do all those things the editors at a traditional publishing house would do for you in ensuring the quality of your finished product. The good news is that there are people you can hire to do everything the editors are doing. And there are a lot of people out on the web who can walk you through doing most, if not all, of the editing and publishing tasks yourself. I’d start with April Hamilton’s the Indie Author Guide. I think there are other books out there and online communities as well.

The Things to Consider before Deciding

Here are a few websites that do a good job of summing up the issues involved in self-publishing versus traditional publishing:

All Things Considered

For me, it makes sense to self-publish. Sure I would love to be able to say, “My book is coming out in November of 2012 from XYZ traditional publishing house.” Prestige, all the way baby. And even though the proponents of traditional publishing say, “The difference between a published author and unpublished writer is persistence,” I may not want to wait as long as it will likely take. Even if I sent out query letters today, and an agent scooped me up and sold my book to a publisher next week, it will be one to two years before it ever sees the inside of a bookstore. (Who knows if there will even still be bookstores by then.) It can take a very long time to find an agent. And then the agent has to find a publisher. I’m just not that patient.

And why should the future of my memoir rely on a brilliant first paragraph in a query letter lost in a stack of hundreds on agents’ desks?

I just want people to read my story.  It’s pretty simple.

I’ll forgo the prestige. I’ll keep the control. And my book will be published. I’ll let the readers decide if it will sell.

15 thoughts on “To indie or not to indie . . . whether ’tis nobler”

  1. Interesting post. Once again, I will be watching closely to see how it goes with you! I have no idea what choice I would make…which is okay since I’m not ready. Can’t wait to see your book, Christine!

  2. Good luck CM. Either way sounds like a huge accomplishment. My not so brilliant queries are buried in that famous slush pile- but please-never say never. LOL.

  3. I am going the e-publishing route as I am an old lady, have “stuff” others have found helpful AND don’t think there is any other way I will get my novel out–providing I am granted time enough to finish it. I do have two hard print books out, and yes added to my credentials, but didn’t sell well enough to endear me to publishers. So it goes. I also think quality sells and from what I have read of your writing, quality it is.

  4. I’m greatly benefiting from your posts about self-publishing. Eighteen months ago, I decided to pursue this route and then ended up pitching my creativity book at the New York Writer’s Digest conference last January. A well-known agent requested the proposal and kindly provided feedback. The bottom line was “Call me when you hit critical mass, over 100,000 blog views per month.”

    I understand why traditional publishers need nonfiction authors to have such a massive following but my reality is far different than celebrity status. I’m a simple teacher just trying to make a living and write a few books along the way. So…I’ve decided that prestige is not in my life’s package. I will, however, buy your book and cheer you on, either way you decide to go.

    1. This was one of the sweetest comments I’ve gotten. We have to stick together, sister. (Either that or commit a heinous crime and make ourselves famous so people will want to read every little thing about us, including our blogs and books.)

  5. I agree , it is a huge undertaking and you will succeed either way.

    If one person reads your book(s) and ‘feels’ what you are writing …you have succeeded. 🙂

    enjoy your journey…you deserve it,



Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: